Is AI Making Us Forget How to Think?

By Kelvin Mutua

Lawyer, Mediator.

I recently watched a university student draft an entire essay without once formulating an original sentence.

She typed a prompt into ChatGPT, copied the output, tweaked a few words, and submitted it within ten minutes. When I asked her what the essay argued, she hesitated.

She had not read it carefully. She had outsourced not just the writing, but the thinking.

This is not an isolated incident. It is a quiet crisis.

Artificial intelligence has brought extraordinary gifts: faster medical diagnoses, efficient legal research, personalized learning tools, and instant summaries of complex documents.

But alongside these benefits, a troubling question emerges. Are we trading our cognitive independence for convenience?

The outsourcing of reflection

Thinking is hard. Real thinking requires patience, discomfort, and the willingness to be wrong.

It demands that we sit with incomplete information, weigh conflicting perspectives, and arrive at a reasoned conclusion.

Also Read: OPINION: How the Registrar of Political Parties Became Kenya’s Newest Battleground

AI offers a shortcut. Why struggle with a difficult email when the tool can write it in seconds? Why wrestle with a complex problem when the chatbot can offer three potential solutions?

The danger is not the tool itself. The danger is habit. Each time we automatically turn to AI without first engaging our own mind, we weaken a mental muscle. Critical thinking, like any skill, atrophies with disuse.

A generation raised on answers

Young people growing up with conversational AI face a particular risk. Previous generations learned to research, verify sources, and construct arguments from scattered information. Today’s learners can receive a polished paragraph instantly.

The process of discovery, with all its false starts and corrections, is disappearing.

Teachers report that students increasingly resist assignments that require step-by-step reasoning.

Why show your work when the machine can skip straight to the answer? The problem is that the answer, without the reasoning that produces it, is hollow.

The illusion of understanding

Perhaps the most insidious effect is cognitive offloading. We mistake the AI’s output for our own understanding. A manager uses AI to draft a strategic plan and believes she has mastered the strategy.

A doctor uses AI to suggest a diagnosis and stops asking his own diagnostic questions. A citizen uses AI to summarize a political debate and never examines the underlying arguments.

We become passengers in our own minds, letting the algorithm navigate while we stare out the window.

What we stand to lose

Human thinking is messy, nonlinear, and deeply contextual. It draws on emotion, experience, empathy, and ethical judgment. AI, for all its power, does not possess these qualities. It simulates reasoning without understanding.

If we stop practicing genuine thought, we risk losing the very capacities that make us wise decision-makers, creative problem-solvers, and moral beings.

Consider a courtroom. An AI can recite precedents, but it cannot sense a witness’s hesitation or weigh the human cost of a ruling. Consider a classroom.

An AI can explain calculus, but it cannot inspire curiosity or recognize a student’s unspoken struggle. Consider a friendship. An AI can suggest comforting words, but it cannot truly care.

A path forward

The answer is not to abandon AI. That ship has sailed. The answer is intentional use.

Use AI as a sparring partner, not a substitute. Before asking the tool for an answer, spend five minutes formulating your own thoughts.

Write down what you know, what you assume, and what you doubt. Then use AI to test, refine, or challenge your thinking.

Teach the next generation to interrogate AI outputs. A generated paragraph is not truth.

It is a probability distribution of words. Young people need to learn to verify facts, identify bias, and ask whether the answer actually makes sense.

Preserve spaces for analogue thinking. Read long articles without skimming. Write by hand occasionally.

Have unstructured conversations where no one reaches for a phone. These practices keep the cognitive machinery lubricated.

Also Read: OPINION: Gachagua’s Anti-Zoning Strategy Could Change Opposition Politics

The bottom line

AI is not making us forget how to think. But convenience can become a crutch, and a crutch can become a cage.

The choice is ours. We can outsource our thinking until we no longer remember how to do it ourselves.

Or we can use AI as a tool that amplifies, rather than replaces, the messy, beautiful, irreplaceable work of the human mind.

Let us choose wisely. Our ability to think for ourselves is too precious to delegate.

Follow our WhatsApp channel for instant news updates